Artwork
Gentle Critics (The Portfolio)

Gentle Critics (The Portfolio) is a watercolor drawing by the Impressionist artist Emily Farmer. It dates from 1872 and is held in the collection of the National Gallery of Art.
About this work
Overview
Emily Farmer’s 1872 work Gentle Critics (The Portfolio) is a watercolor drawing on wove paper, incorporating traces of graphite, gum arabic and white gouache. The piece is part of the National Gallery of Art’s collection in Washington, D.C., and measures the intimate interaction of two young girls within a modest interior setting.
Subject & Meaning
The composition depicts an older girl holding an open book while a younger companion leans forward to view its pages. Their attire—a light dress with a blue collar for the elder and a dark dress with a blue sash and a red hair bow for the younger—suggests a quiet moment of shared reading or instruction, emphasizing themes of mentorship and domestic learning.
Technique & Style
Farmer employs loose, sketch‑like brushwork that conveys immediacy, while the watercolor palette is restrained to soft pinks, blues, and earth tones. Highlights of white gouache accentuate light falling through a nearby window, creating a subtle atmospheric glow across the plain brown walls.
History & Provenance
Created in 1872, the drawing entered the National Gallery of Art’s holdings through acquisition (details of the purchase are not publicly recorded). Its presence in the museum underscores the artist’s contribution to 19th‑century British watercolor practice.













