Artwork
Plate 6: Two Views of a Mourning Cloak (Camberwell Beauty) Butterfly with a Comma Butterfly

Plate 6: Two Views of a Mourning Cloak (Camberwell Beauty) Butterfly with a Comma Butterfly is a gouache drawing by the Renaissance artist Joris Hoefnagel. It dates from 1594 and is held in the collection of the National Gallery of Art.
About this work
Overview
Created around 1594, this small-scale work by Flemish artist Joris Hoefnagel presents two views of a Mourning Cloak (Camberwell Beauty) butterfly alongside a Comma butterfly. Executed on parchment with watercolor, lepidochromy and touches of gold, the composition places the insects against a muted cream background, emphasizing their delicate coloration and fine structural details.
Subject & Meaning
The drawing focuses on the natural forms of two lepidopteran species, highlighting the contrasting wing patterns of the larger Mourning Cloak and the smaller Comma. By portraying the insects with scientific exactness, Hoefnagel underscores the emerging interest in cataloguing nature during the late Renaissance, offering a visual study rather than allegorical narrative.
Technique & Style
Hoefnagel combines traditional watercolor washes with lepidochromy—a method that enhances the translucency of pigment—to render the butterflies' subtle hues. Fine gold leaf accents punctuate the wing edges, while meticulous line work creates texture and depth. The overall effect balances the precision of natural history illustration with the decorative elegance typical of manuscript illumination.
History & Provenance
The piece belongs to a series of natural history plates produced by Hoefnagel in the 1590s, a period when he was active as a miniaturist and topographical draughtsman. Although the original manuscript context is unclear, the work reflects his contribution to the early development of scientific illustration in northern Europe.
Context
At the turn of the 17th century, Flemish artists began integrating detailed botanical and zoological subjects into decorative arts. Hoefnagel’s interest in accurate observation aligns with contemporary scientific endeavors, while his use of gold and refined rendering connects the drawing to the tradition of illuminated manuscripts.
Legacy
Hoefnagel’s meticulous butterfly studies anticipate later naturalists such as Maria Sibylla Merian. The combination of artistic refinement and empirical observation in this plate helped shape the visual language of early modern scientific illustration.
Artist & collection
Artist
Joris Hoefnagel or Georg Hoefnagel (1542 – 24 July 1601) was a Flemish painter, printmaker, miniaturist, draftsman and merchant.



















